Alligator Penny

Name: Alligator Penny
Brand: May Anthony
Price: 269.00 USD
Availability: InStock

$269.00 USD

US, EU, UK Sizing

US SIZE

Width

Width Options Explained

STANDARD: Designed to comfortably fit most foot shapes with average or medium width. Provides a well-balanced fit straight out of the box — no break-in needed for most.

WIDE (E): Slightly more generous through the forefoot and instep. Ideal if you typically buy wide-width shoes or prefer extra space.

If you typically wear EE, EEE, or require wider widths, please include this in your order notes at checkout — we’ll adjust your pair accordingly.

Each pair is individually handmade, just for you.

RETURNS & EXCHANGES

All orders are eligible for returns or exchanges within 21 days of delivery. Items must be unworn, unused, and returned in their original condition.

See our Returns & Exchanges page for details.

Secure Checkout Available With

Our Alligator Penny Loafers excudes timeless sophistication. Crafted from premium patterned alligator leather, these loafers showcase a sleek and enduring design, making them the perfect statement piece for the discerning gentleman. Slip them on and elevate your style with unmatched elegance.

Leather Lined Insole for extra support & comfort
Premium Leather Sole with a stacked heel for durability and elegance
Perfect Gift for a loved one
Runs True to Size

Our Handcrafted Process

Premium Material Selection

Precision Pattern Cutting

Individually Handmade

Sole Attachment

Rigorous Quality Control

Final Polishing & Finishing

Alligator Penny

$269.00 USD

Need help?

Frequently Asked Questions

What materials are your shoes made from?

Our shoes are crafted from high-quality materials, which may vary by style. You can find detailed information about the materials used in each product's description on the product page.

Are your shoes true to size?

Our shoes are designed to be true to size, but individual fit preferences may vary. We recommend checking our size chart and reaching out to us for additional sizing guidance.

What size should I order?

As our shoes run true to size, we recommend you order the same size you wear for similarly styled shoes.

If you need additional help, please send an email to hello@mayanthony.com

Are your products ethically and sustainably made?

We are committed to ethical and sustainable practices. We source materials responsibly and prioritize fair labor practices. You can learn more about our sustainability initiatives on our About Us page.

Can I return or exchange my purchase if it doesn't fit?

Yes, we have a hassle-free return and exchange policy. If your shoes don't fit as expected, you can return or exchange them within our specified timeframe. Please see our Shipping & Returns page for details.

How can I track my order's status?

After placing an order, you will receive a confirmation email with a tracking link. You can also log in to your account to view your order's status and tracking information.

What is your warranty policy?

We stand by the quality of our products. Our shoes come with a lifetime warranty against manufacturing defects. For specific warranty details, please send us an email hello@mayanthony.com

Do you offer half sizes?

Yes, we offer half sizes for most of our styles. If a half size is available, you can select it from the size options on the product page.

Do you offer wide fit options?

Yes, our shoes are all individually handmade so we are able to make shoes for different foot sizes and widths. For further information, please send an email to hello@mayanthony.com

How do I care for my new shoes?

Proper care can extend the life of your shoes. Check the care instructions provided on the product page, but in general, you should clean them regularly, avoid extreme conditions, and store them properly.